Toronto's real estate market is showing signs of strain, as RBC's Greater Toronto Area (GTA) mortgage portfolio saw serious delinquencies surge by 42% in Q3 2024. The serious delinquency rate, now at 0.27%, is 170% higher than last year, signaling financial distress for homeowners. Government intervention is only delaying the problem, as recent buyers-particularly investors-face mounting challenges in exiting the market. Despite rising delinquencies, home prices have remained stable, reflecting deeper issues within Canada's largest real estate market.
Canada's largest real estate market, the Greater Toronto Area (GTA), is showing troubling signs as mortgage delinquencies escalate, particularly for RBC, the nation's biggest bank. In Q3 2024, serious mortgage delinquencies (those delinquent for over 90 days) in RBC's GTA portfolio soared, revealing deeper cracks in what has long been considered a resilient housing market. Despite stable home prices, growing delinquencies suggest underlying financial strains that could have significant long-term repercussions.
As of Q3 2024, the serious delinquency rate for RBC's GTA mortgage portfolio jumped to 0.27%, marking a staggering 42% increase from the previous quarter and a rise of 170% compared to the same period last year. This sharp uptick is not only higher than the national average for the bank but also exceeds the levels seen during the 2017 mini-foreign buyer bubble. The speed at which these offenses are climbing has raised alarms, as it highlights growing financial pressure on homeowners in one of the country's most expensive real estate markets.
Experts point out that government interventions, designed to temporarily ease financial distress during periods of economic scrutiny, may be partly responsible for the delay in recognizing the full extent of the problem. While such measures may reduce the immediate number of delinquencies, they only serve to postpone the inevitable. These interventions can artificially suppress the delinquency rate, but they don't address the underlying liquidity issues faced by many homeowners. As a result, the financial challenges intensify, setting the stage for more severe consequences down the line.
The delayed cohort of homeowners-those who have managed to hold off on defaulting through temporary relief measures-now find themselves in a more precarious position. These sellers, once able to sell their properties before falling into default, now face stiffer competition as the number of seriously delinquent sellers grows. The market dynamics are shifting rapidly, making it harder for distressed sellers to exit gracefully before their financial situation worsens.
One of the more alarming indicators is the stability of real estate prices in the GTA despite these growing delinquencies. Ordinarily, a rise in mortgage defaults would signal a drop in home prices as distressed properties flood the market. However, Toronto's property values have remained relatively stable, leading some to believe that the extent of the problem is being masked. The fact that prices haven't adjusted downward suggests that many of the properties tied to delinquent mortgages belong to recent buyers, possibly investors, who may be unwilling or unable to sell at a loss.
Many of these newer homeowners, who entered the market during the past few years, have seen their equity wiped out as market conditions stagnate. For these owners, lowering the price to sell the property isn't a viable option. Selling at a lower price would mean paying out of pocket to cover the difference between the sale price and the remaining mortgage balance. As a result, many of these investors or recent buyers find themselves in a financial deadlock, unable to sell without incurring significant losses.
The overall picture in Toronto's real estate market is becoming increasingly complex. While on the surface, prices have held steady, the rise in serious delinquencies points to deeper financial challenges for homeowners and investors alike. The GTA, which has long been a hotspot for real estate investment, is now showing signs of strain as a growing number of homeowners struggle to meet their mortgage obligations.